---
title: Why We Overvalue Formal Learning and Undervalue Performance Support
description: We’ve been trained to overvalue formal learning — but in the workplace, simple performance support often makes the biggest difference.
image: https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/hubfs/getty-images-crMp8FLWHX4-unsplash.jpg
---

****

[![pacific-blue-logo-white](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/hs-fs/hubfs/White%20transparent.png?width=520&height=105&name=White%20transparent.png)

![Pacific Blue Logo](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/hs-fs/hubfs/Corporate%20blue%20transparent.png?width=520&height=105&name=Corporate%20blue%20transparent.png) 

](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk)

[![LET'S TALK](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/31306/0bee0e88-7dab-4481-aa27-3e0ea6439460.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/31306/0bee0e88-7dab-4481-aa27-3e0ea6439460)

[**](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/learning-academy-blog/why-we-overvalue-formal-learning-and-undervalue-performance-support#tmpmodule_1568761248550301)

**

#### Evaluating Training Effectivenes

[![mega-menu-graphic](https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/s/f5zha8dh6586r0z/mega-menu-graphic.jpg "mega-menu-graphic")](https://marketplace.hubspot.com/products/design-with-speed/clean-premium-pack)

#### Learning Re-Framed In-House Programme

#### Articulate Storyline

#### Storyline In-House Programmes

#### Storyline Scheduled Public Courses

#### Course Bookings

![Complete ID Brochure Image - CLEAN](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/hubfs/Complete%20ID%20Brochure%20Image%20-%20CLEAN.png "Complete ID Brochure Image - CLEAN")

#### E-Learning Design & Development Services

[![Happy in front of laptops](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/hubfs/Happy%20in%20front%20of%20laptops.jpg "Happy in front of laptops")](https://marketplace.hubspot.com/products/design-with-speed/clean-premium-pack)

#### Other Design & Development Services

![placeholder_200x200](https://static.hubspot.com/final/img/content/email-template-images/placeholder_200x200.png "placeholder_200x200")

#### More

![Customers](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/hubfs/Customers.jpg "Customers")

###### 2 min read

# [Why We Overvalue Formal Learning and Undervalue Performance Support](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/learning-academy-blog/why-we-overvalue-formal-learning-and-undervalue-performance-support)

 By [Andrew Jackson](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/learning-academy-blog/author/andrew-jackson) on Tue, Oct 21,2025

###### Topics: [Performance Support](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/learning-academy-blog/topic/performance-support) [Learning Impact](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/learning-academy-blog/topic/learning-impact)

![Working through a checklist](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/hubfs/getty-images-crMp8FLWHX4-unsplash.jpg)

Ask anyone outside of L&D what comes to mind when they think of “learning,” and the answer is almost always the same: classrooms, courses, qualifications.

That’s not surprising. From the time we’re four or five years old, we spend hours of our lives in an education system where the ultimate prize is being good at school. Success is measured in grades, certificates, and diplomas. Society reinforces the message: the more successful you are at completing formal learning, the more valuable you are.

So, it’s no wonder that when business leaders run into a performance problem, their first instinct is to ask L&D for training. Courses feel like the answer because courses are what we’ve all been conditioned to believe in.

The Blind Spot This Creates  
The problem is, formal learning isn’t always the lever that moves performance. In fact, often it’s not even close.

Sometimes what’s needed isn’t weeks of training. Sometimes it’s something as simple as a single page of A4 paper — a job aid, a checklist, a quick reference — that gives people exactly what they need, when they need it.

But here’s the counterintuitive part: because these solutions look so simple, they often get dismissed. People inevitably think, “How could something that small make a real difference?”

This bias towards formal learning is a big blind spot in how we approach workplace learning. It’s why L&D so often gets trapped in the order-taking cycle — asked to churn out courses because they’re seen as the “serious” answer, even when simpler, leaner performance support would have more impact.

Why Simplicity Works  
The irony is that simplicity is exactly what makes performance support powerful:

•    A well-designed checklist can significantly reduces errors.  
•    A short job aid can save hours of wasted time.  
•    A contextual nudge can shift behaviour more effectively than any course module.

None of these examples look like the formal learning solutions we’ve been trained to overvalue. But they work; and often, they work better.

Shifting Our Mindset in L&D  
If we  want to increase learning impact, we need to challenge the cultural over-perception of formal learning. That doesn’t mean courses don’t matter. It means we stop treating them as the default solution.

It means educating our stakeholders that effectiveness isn’t about how long or formal a learning solution is, but about how well it supports performance. Sometimes that’s a course. Sometimes it’s workplace support. And sometimes it’s a combination of both.

A Closing Thought...  
The world has taught us to equate learning with classrooms, exams, and certificates. But in the workplace, those aren’t always what move the needle.

Performance improves when people have the right support at the right time. And sometimes, that support looks a lot less like school — and a lot more like a single sheet of paper.

- [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share)

![Andrew Jackson](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/hubfs/andrew-jackson-profile.jpg)

#### Written by [Andrew Jackson](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/learning-academy-blog/author/andrew-jackson)

Hi, I’m Andrew Jackson — co-founder of Pacific Blue Solutions and founder of Pacific Blue AI. I’ve spent almost 20 years helping L&D teams design learning that actually changes what people do at work. Alongside my weekly writing on Learning Re-Framed, this Learning Academy blog is where I share practical, evidence-based ideas for improving learning design and performance support in a changing, AI-enabled world.

[**](https://www.linkedin.com/in/andrewtjackson/)

###### [** Previous Post](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/learning-academy-blog/from-training-order-takers-to-performance-enablers)

[![The L&D lady takes training orders from her colleagues](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/hubfs/AI-Generated%20Media/Images/This%20is%20a%20workplace%20setting%20The%20view%20is%20angled%20from%20the%20side%20We%20can%20see%20a%20desk%20with%20a%20rather%20harasssed%20looking%20woman%20standing%20behind%20the%20desk%20talking%20to%20the%20person%20at%20the%20fron%20of%20the%20line%20Hanging%20above%20the%20desk%20is%20a%20big%20sign%20that%20says%20Orders%20Theres%20a.jpeg) ](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/learning-academy-blog/from-training-order-takers-to-performance-enablers)

###### [From Order-Taker to Performance Enabler - a Shift L&D Can't Ignore](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/learning-academy-blog/from-training-order-takers-to-performance-enablers)

###### [Next Post **](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/learning-academy-blog/design-thinking-not-coding-the-real-ai-skill-for-ld)

[![Design thinking and logic](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/hubfs/AI-Generated%20Media/Images/photographic%20An%20abstract%20image%20that%20conveys%20the%20idea%20of%20design%20thinking%20and%20logic.png) ](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/learning-academy-blog/design-thinking-not-coding-the-real-ai-skill-for-ld)

###### [Design Thinking, Not Coding: The Real AI Skill for L&D](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/learning-academy-blog/design-thinking-not-coding-the-real-ai-skill-for-ld)

##### Impact and Instructional Design - Guides

Impact and Instructional Design - Guides

##### Learning Re-Framed Programmes

Learning Re-Framed Programmes

##### Storyline Training - Courses

Storyline Training - Courses

##### E-Learning Design - Guides and Toolkits

E-Learning Design - Guides and Toolkits

[![White transparent-2](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/hs-fs/hubfs/White%20transparent-2.png?width=150&height=30&name=White%20transparent-2.png "White transparent-2")](https://www.pacificblue.co.uk)

Copyright © 2026 Pacific Blue Solutions Ltd

**

![](https://googleads.g.doubleclick.net/pagead/viewthroughconversion/1071354352/?value=0&guid=ON&script=0)

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Andrew Jackson",
    "url" : "https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/learning-academy-blog/author/andrew-jackson"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2025-10-21T10:00:02.151Z",
  "datePublished" : "2025-10-21T10:00:02.000Z",
  "headline" : "Why We Overvalue Formal Learning and Undervalue Performance Support",
  "image" : [ "https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/hubfs/getty-images-crMp8FLWHX4-unsplash.jpg" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/learning-academy-blog/why-we-overvalue-formal-learning-and-undervalue-performance-support",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://www.pacificblue.co.uk/hs-fs/images/communicating-information-22.png"
    },
    "name" : "Pacific Blue Solutions"
  }
}
```